O&G Vivas · Critical care — escalation and safety-net
Obstetric early warning scores and escalation — structured oral station (12 minutes)
FRANZCOG oral-format station on a triggered obstetric early warning score: candidate manages from the bedside, defends the design and validation of obstetric EWS (Singh, Shields, Hedriana, Edwards), reproduces the MEWT triggers verbatim, and escalates with SBAR. Scored against the eight published RANZCOG oral domains.
On this page & tools
Target exams
Station format
4 minutes reading, 12 minutes examination, 20 marks, global scoring. The eight published RANZCOG oral domains apply to every station: history and examination; investigations and interpreting results; treatment and management; clinical knowledge; complex, urgent or unusual clinical presentations; rapport with patient, support person or colleague; respect; communication skills. You are being marked on how you behave, not only what you know. [5][6]
Reveal the examiner script and model responses
Opening prompt — "Tell me what you do at the bedside, in the first ten minutes."
Model response — say it in this order: [5][6]
- "This is a multi-parameter trigger with fever and tachypnoea — I am worried about evolving sepsis with possible genital tract or wound source. I would call my consultant now and put them on speaker."
- "Bedside ABCDE: 15-degree left lateral tilt, high-flow oxygen, two large-bore cannulae, balanced crystalloid, bloods including lactate and cultures, crossmatch, coagulation with fibrinogen."
- "Focused source hunt: examine the perineum and episiotomy, the uterus, the lochia, the chest, the urine; bedside ultrasound for free fluid or retained products."
- "SBAR handover to my consultant and to the anaesthetist: situation, background, assessment, recommendation — I want HDU transfer and the sepsis bundle activated."[5][6]
Examiner is listening for: parallel action, named role for the call, the SBAR sentence, and recognition that a multi-parameter trigger with fever is sepsis until proven otherwise. [5]
Probe 1 — "Walk me through the design of an obstetric early warning score."
- "There are two architectural families. Aggregate-weighted scoring (MEOWS) assigns points for each parameter's deviation from normal and sums them — a total above a threshold triggers. Single-parameter triggering (MEWT) uses one sustained abnormal value — no summation."[1][3]
- "The chart must use pregnancy-specific thresholds. A HR of 95, a BP of 95/55, a RR of 20 are normal late in pregnancy; the chart flags deviation from the pregnant baseline, not the non-pregnant baseline."[6]
- "The chart is only useful paired with an escalation pathway. A documented trigger that is not acted on is the commonest failure mode in maternal mortality enquiries."[5]
Probe 2 — "What is the evidence that MEOWS works?"
- "Singh 2012, in Anaesthesia, validated the CEMACH MEOWS in 676 consecutive obstetric admissions — 30% triggered, 13% had morbidity. Sensitivity 89%, specificity 79%, PPV 39%, NPV 98%. The strength is the high NPV; the weakness is the false-positive burden."[1]
- "Shields 2016 showed MEWT implementation reduced maternal morbidity. Hedriana 2016 showed two or more persistent triggers for 30 minutes carried OR 61.7 for ICU admission."[3][4]
- "Edwards 2015 validated modified obstetric scores against severe sepsis in chorioamnionitis. And the Cochrane review by Smith in 2021 is honest about the low certainty of the evidence base — the chart you embed and audit outperforms the chart you admire."[2]
Probe 3 — "Quote me the MEWT severe single-value triggers."
- "Maternal heart rate above 130, respiratory rate above 30, mean arterial pressure under 55, oxygen saturation under 90, altered mental status, or nurse concern."[3]
- "Each is sustained for more than 20 minutes. That persistence requirement filters the post-epidural or anxiety tachycardia from the real slope toward decompensation."[3][4]
Probe 4 — "The midwife wrote 'doesn't look right' in the margin. How do you handle that?"
This is a scored domain, not a courtesy. Demonstrate it out loud: [3]
- "Nurse concern is a legitimate trigger, not a courtesy — I treat that note as a sixth vital sign. I go to the bedside myself, I ask the midwife what she is worried about, and I take her concern into my assessment."
- "If the obs had been normal and the nurse concern alone was present, I would still escalate to a bedside review within 30 minutes and document my findings and a plan."
- "I would thank her at the bedside for raising the concern — it is the cultural change that makes the chart useful."[3][5]
Probe 5 — "After your interventions she is stable but the working diagnosis is sepsis from the episiotomy. Where does she go?"
- "HDU. She meets the criteria — persistent multi-parameter trigger, evolving sepsis, post-operative. I would transfer her with a documented safety-net, a named accepting clinician, and a clear plan for what to do if she deteriorates en route."[5]
- "Post-event: serial lactate, serial bloods, ongoing source control, daily VTE risk reassessment once sepsis is controlled, structured debrief with the woman and the team, and an incident and near-miss review reporting back into the unit's audit of obstetric EWS performance."[5]
- "Next pregnancy: counsel about recurrence of postpartum sepsis and a documented postnatal observation plan."[5]
You have read the opening of this viva. The complete unit — every section and its primary-source references — is part of the Obstetrics & Gynaecology fellowship atlas.
References6Show ledgerHide ledger
- [1]Singh S, McGlennan A, England A, Simons R A validation study of the CEMACH recommended modified early obstetric warning system (MEOWS) Anaesthesia, 2012.PMID 22066604
- [2]Edwards SE, Grobman WA, Lappen JR, Winter C, Fox R, Lenguerrand E, Draycott T Modified obstetric early warning scoring systems (MOEWS): validating the diagnostic performance for severe sepsis in women with chorioamnionitis Am J Obstet Gynecol, 2015.PMID 25446705
- [3]Shields LE, Wiesner S, Klein C, Pelletreau B, Hedriana HL Use of Maternal Early Warning Trigger tool reduces maternal morbidity Am J Obstet Gynecol, 2016.PMID 26924745
- [4]Hedriana HL, Wiesner S, Downs BG, Pelletreau B, Shields LE Baseline assessment of a hospital-specific early warning trigger system for reducing maternal morbidity Int J Gynaecol Obstet, 2016.PMID 26797195
- [5]Friedman AM, Campbell ML, Kline CR, Wiesner S, D'Alton M, Shields LE Implementing Obstetric Early Warning Systems AJP Rep, 2018.PMID 29686937
- [6]Chu J, Johnston TA, Geoghegan J Maternal Collapse in Pregnancy and the Puerperium: Green-top Guideline No. 56 BJOG, 2020.PMID 31845507