O&G SAQs · Antenatal care — maternal malignancy
Breast cancer diagnosed in pregnancy — structured SAQ (15 marks)
FRANZCOG-format structured SAQ on breast cancer diagnosed in pregnancy: triple assessment, surgical management with sentinel node biopsy, chemotherapy timing rules, the contraindications (tamoxifen, trastuzumab, checkpoint inhibitors), and the consult-series framework on multidisciplinary care, delivery timing and placental pathology. Per-sub-part marking rubric included.
On this page
Study tools
Target exams
How this SAQ is marked
Twelve SAQs, 180 marks, two 2-hour papers — roughly 15 marks and 20 minutes each. Marks come from specifics: the imaging modality, the biopsy technique, the agent and its contraindication, the gestation threshold, the treatment-free window before delivery. Write in short labelled points, not prose paragraphs. Answer the sub-part you are asked.[1][2]
Reveal model answer and mark schemeShowHide
(a) Diagnostic principles — triple assessment (3 marks)
One mark per principle, maximum three. [1][2]
- Triple assessment as outside pregnancy — clinical examination, imaging (ultrasound first-line; mammography acceptable with abdominal shielding of the case being reconsidered per modern guidance), and tissue sampling. Pregnancy changes the texture of the breast but not the workup.
- Core needle biopsy is the preferred tissue technique — FNA is less reliable in the gravid, lactating breast because of the cellularularity of normal pregnancy change.
- Pregnancy is not a reason to defer diagnosis — a persistent, dominant, discretely palpable mass in pregnancy is worked up immediately; the six-week delay in this case is the failure mode the question is testing.[1]
(b) Surgical management and axillary staging (4 marks)
One mark per principle, maximum four. [2][5]
- Surgery is safe at any gestation — mastectomy or wide local excision can be performed in pregnancy. Anaesthesia in pregnancy is safe with left lateral tilt and capnography.
- Sentinel lymph node biopsy using 99mTc-labelled nanocolloid is the preferred axillary staging — the INCIP series (Han 2018) of 145 women showed a low axillary recurrence rate (0.7% isolated ipsilateral axillary recurrence at 48-month follow-up) comparable to non-pregnant women, with no neonatal adverse events.[5]
- Blue dye is avoided because of the small risk of anaphylaxis and uncertain fetal safety.
- Radiotherapy is deferred to postpartum — when radiotherapy would be required during pregnancy, mastectomy is the preferred operation to avoid an inadequate operation. The decision between mastectomy and breast-conserving surgery accounts for the radiotherapy timing.
(c) Systemic therapy — chemotherapy, radiotherapy, endocrine, HER2-targeted (5 marks)
One mark per named agent or timing rule, maximum five. [2][4][6]
- Chemotherapy after the first trimester (guideline-endorsed). The first trimester is the malformation window because of organogenesis; anthracycline- and taxane-based regimens administered after the first trimester have not shown an excess of congenital malformation. The INCIP comparison of pregnant breast cancer patients treated with chemotherapy versus non-pregnant controls showed comparable outcomes.[4]
- Stop most chemotherapy by 34 weeks to allow marrow recovery before delivery, with a treatment-free window of around three weeks before birth.[6]
- Radiotherapy deferred to postpartum (as above).
- Tamoxifen is contraindicated for clinical use in pregnancy — stopped before conception, withheld until postpartum, with barrier contraception during treatment and for three months after stopping before attempting conception. An inadvertent exposure is not an automatic indication for termination — counsel and continue.[7]
- Trastuzumab is avoided — associated with oligohydramnios, fetal renal injury, and a recognised risk of irreversible fetal renal damage. HER2-targeted therapy is typically deferred to postpartum.
- Checkpoint inhibitors are avoided in pregnancy because of fetomaternal immune-tolerance disruption; decisions made individually for metastatic disease.[8]
(d) Multidisciplinary team, delivery timing, placental pathology (3 marks)
One mark per element, maximum three. [1][2]
- Multidisciplinary team — maternal–fetal medicine, medical oncology, surgical oncology, anaesthesia, neonatology, perinatal mental health, a pathologist, and the woman herself. The Advisory Board on Cancer, Infertility and Pregnancy provides a virtual on-demand tumour board for centres without local expertise.
- Delivery-timing rules — avoid planned delivery before 37 weeks unless medically indicated; stop most chemotherapy by 34 weeks for marrow recovery; aim for a treatment-free window of around three weeks before birth.
- Placental pathology in every case of cancer during pregnancy (guideline-endorsed) — the only way to detect placental metastasis, which (particularly for melanoma and lung cancer) is the signal that the neonate needs lifelong surveillance.[2]
References8ShowHide
- [1]Peccatori FA, Azim HA Jr, Orecchia R, et al. Cancer, pregnancy and fertility: ESMO Clinical Practice Guidelines for diagnosis, treatment and follow-up Ann Oncol, 2013.PMID 23813932
- [2]Loibl S, Azim HA Jr, Bachelot T, et al. ESMO Expert Consensus Statements on the management of breast cancer during pregnancy (PrBC) Ann Oncol, 2023.PMID 37572987
- [3]Amant F, von Minckwitz G, Han SN, et al. Prognosis of women with primary breast cancer diagnosed during pregnancy: results from an international collaborative study J Clin Oncol, 2013.PMID 23610117
- [4]Amant F, Nekljudova V, Maggen C, et al. Outcome of breast cancer patients treated with chemotherapy during pregnancy compared with non-pregnant controls Eur J Cancer, 2022.PMID 35594612
- [5]Han SN, Amant F, Cardonick EH, et al. Axillary staging for breast cancer during pregnancy: feasibility and safety of sentinel lymph node biopsy Breast Cancer Res Treat, 2018.PMID 29235045
- [6]Vandenbroucke T, Verheecke M, Fumagalli M, et al. Effects of cancer treatment during pregnancy on fetal and child development Lancet Child Adolesc Health, 2017.PMID 30169185
- [7]Schuurman TN, Witteveen PO, van der Wall E, et al. Tamoxifen and pregnancy: an absolute contraindication? Breast Cancer Res Treat, 2019.PMID 30707336
- [8]Borgers JSW, Heimovaara JH, Cardonick E, et al. Immunotherapy for cancer treatment during pregnancy Lancet Oncol, 2021.PMID 34856152