EM Vivas · Aspiration pneumonia and lung abscess
Aspiration — the pneumonitis versus the pneumonia
A clinical viva on the pneumonitis-pneumonia distinction.
On this page
Study tools
Target exams
ACEMFRCEMABEM
Prompt
Distinguish the aspiration pneumonitis from the aspiration pneumonia, and describe the management of each.
Interpretation
Reveal interpretationShowHide
The aspiration pneumonitis:
- The chemical, the sterile injury from the gastric acid.
- The rapid onset (the hours), the hypoxia, the wheeze, the bilateral infiltrates.
- The common in the obstetric (the pregnant, the full stomach) and the anaesthetic patient.
- The management: the supportive (the oxygen, the airway protection, the observation). The NO routine antibiotics (unless the secondary infection). The corticosteroids and the lavage NOT recommended.[1]
The aspiration pneumonia:
- The bacterial infection from the oropharyngeal contents.
- The insidious onset (the days), the fever, the cough, the purulent and the foul-smelling sputum (the anaerobes).
- The risk factors — reduced glottic competency (extreme age, esophageal neuromuscular disease, intubation, impaired consciousness), altered consciousness, alcohol and poor dentition.
- Ill-defined infiltrates with hypoxia — a disease of exclusion; most events are silent or unwitnessed.
- The management: scenario-matched antibiotics — extended anaerobic cover beyond CAP therapy added no mortality benefit; the putrid abscess is the clindamycin domain.[1]
The key distinction: the pneumonitis is the sterile chemical injury (supportive), the pneumonia is the bacterial infection (antibiotics) — though differentiation can be very difficult. The foul-smelling sputum and fever favour the pneumonia.[1]
References1ShowHide
- [1]Raghavendran K, Nemzek J, Napolitano LM, Knight PR Aspiration-induced lung injury Crit Care Med, 2011.PMID 21263315