Expert evidence and forensic report writing

Also known as Expert evidence psychiatry · Forensic report writing · Psychiatric expert witness · Medico-legal report psychiatry · Forensic mental health assessment report · Expert testimony psychiatry · Independent medical examination report psychiatry · Court report forensic psychiatry

Exam-exhaustive fellowship reference on psychiatric expert evidence and forensic report writing: expert vs fact/treating roles, dual-role ethics, forensic assessment method (AAPL), structured report architecture, oral testimony and cross-examination, bias and reliability, ultimate-issue limits, and admissibility principles (Frye/Daubert-type teaching). Jurisdiction principles only — no invented statute section numbers. FRANZCP-primary, globally tagged.

high18 referencesUpdated 26 July 202615 min readVerification in progress

Practise this topic

10 MCQs

Meet the referral

A solicitor's letter arrives. You have treated the client for four years. The letter asks for "an independent expert report" on whether her psychiatric injury is permanent, encloses 40 pages of a 400-page file, and notes that the hearing is in nine days.^[7]^[18]

A second paragraph adds, helpfully, that "our client's position is that she is totally and permanently incapacitated".^[17]^[18]

Three separate failures are already available to you and most trainees take at least one: accepting a dual role without disclosing it, accepting a partial file as if it were the file, and letting the instructing party's preferred conclusion set the frame.^[7]^[10]^[17]

References18Show

[1]Glancy GD, Ash P, Bath EP, et al. AAPL Practice Guideline for the Forensic Assessment J Am Acad Psychiatry Law, 2015.PMID 26054704
[2]Vasile M, Hamalian G, Wortzel HS New Guidelines for Forensic Assessment J Psychiatr Pract, 2016.PMID 27138081
[3]Young G Psychiatric/ psychological forensic report writing Int J Law Psychiatry, 2016.PMID 28029436
[4]Appelbaum KL Commentary: the art of forensic report writing J Am Acad Psychiatry Law, 2010.PMID 20305073
[5]Wettstein RM Commentary: conceptualizing the forensic psychiatry report J Am Acad Psychiatry Law, 2010.PMID 20305074
[6]Weinstock R Commentary: The forensic report--an inevitable nexus for resolving ethics dilemmas J Am Acad Psychiatry Law, 2013.PMID 24051589
[7]Strasburger LH, Gutheil TG, Brodsky A On wearing two hats: role conflict in serving as both psychotherapist and expert witness Am J Psychiatry, 1997.PMID 9090330
[8]Appelbaum PS The parable of the forensic psychiatrist: ethics and the problem of doing harm Int J Law Psychiatry, 1990.PMID 2286491
[9]Appelbaum PS A theory of ethics for forensic psychiatry J Am Acad Psychiatry Law, 1997.PMID 9323651
[10]Appelbaum PS Ethics and forensic psychiatry: translating principles into practice J Am Acad Psychiatry Law, 2008.PMID 18583695
[11]Chaplow DG, Peters JL, Kydd RR The expert witness in forensic psychiatry Aust N Z J Psychiatry, 1992.PMID 1476528
[12]Gutheil TG The presentation of forensic psychiatric evidence in court Isr J Psychiatry Relat Sci, 2000.PMID 10994298
[13]Glancy GD, Saini M The confluence of evidence-based practice and Daubert within the fields of forensic psychiatry and the law J Am Acad Psychiatry Law, 2009.PMID 20018992
[14]Buchanan A Psychiatric evidence on the ultimate issue J Am Acad Psychiatry Law, 2006.PMID 16585229
[15]Large MM, Nielssen O Factors associated with agreement between experts in evidence about psychiatric injury J Am Acad Psychiatry Law, 2008.PMID 19092070
[16]Large M, Nielssen O, Elliott G The reliability of evidence about psychiatric diagnosis after serious crime: Part I. Agreement between experts J Am Acad Psychiatry Law, 2010.PMID 21156911
[17]Forrester A Clinical and scientific expert witness bias: Sources and expression Med Sci Law, 2020.PMID 32272871
[18]Samuels AH Civil Forensic Psychiatry - part 3: practical aspects of managing a medico-legal practice Australas Psychiatry, 2018.PMID 29457467