Subtalar Arthritis
Summary
Subtalar Arthritis is the degeneration of the talocalcaneal joint, predominantly affecting the Posterior Facet. Like the ankle, it is overwhelmingly Post-Traumatic in origin, most commonly following a Calcaneal Fracture (intra-articular) or Talus Fracture. Patients present with a distinct inability to walk on uneven ground ("cobblestones"), as the subtalar joint's primary function is accommodating terrain (inversion/eversion). Management is initially conservative (bracing) but often progresses to Subtalar Fusion (Arthrodesis), which is one of the most successful operations in foot and ankle surgery with >90% satisfaction rates. [1,2,3]
Key Facts
- The Accommodator: The subtalar joint converts the rotation of the leg into inversion/eversion of the foot, allowing us to walk on non-flat surfaces. Loss of this joint (arthritis or fusion) means the patient struggles on hills or rocky ground.
- The "Widened Heel": After Calcaneal fractures, the heel often heals "short and wide" (Blowout), causing lateral impingement against the fibula.
- The Coalition Factor: In patients with no history of trauma, suspect a Tarsal Coalition (Middle facet) that has altered mechanics for decades.
Clinical Pearls
"The Cobblestone Sign": Ask the patient: "Can you walk on a beach or a gravel driveway?" If they say "No, it hurts deeply," it is Subtalar Arthritis. Ankle arthritis patients struggle more with hills (dorsiflexion).
"Where is the pain?": Subtalar pain is felt in the Sinus Tarsi (lateral) or deep in the heel. It is NOT usually felt anteriorly (Ankle).
"The Diagnostic Block": Because Ankle and Subtalar pain overlap (and 20% exist together), injecting the Subtalar joint with local anesthetic is mandatory before surgery to confirm the pain source.
Demographics
- Etiology:
- Post-Traumatic (75%): Calcaneal Fracture (Sanders II-IV), Talus Fracture.
- Primary (10%).
- Coalition (10%): Long standing middle facet coalition.
- Rheumatoid (5%).
Anatomy
- Facets: Posterior (largest, weight bearing), Middle (Sustentaculum), Anterior.
- Motion: Tri-planar (Inversion/Adduction/Plantarflexion vs Eversion/Abduction/Dorsiflexion).
Pathomechanics
- Calcaneal Malunion:
- Varus: Locks the Chopart joint (Rigid foot).
- Valgus: Unlocks the Chopart joint (Flat foot).
- Height Loss: Decreased Talar declination angle -> Anterior impingement.
Symptoms
Signs
Imaging
- X-Ray (Weight Bearing):
- Lateral: Loss of joint space at posterior facet. Sclerosis.
- Harris (Axial) View: Essential to see the joint line and heel width.
- Broden View: Oblique view for posterior facet.
- CT Scan:
- Definitive for assessing the degree of arthritis and malalignment.
- Checks for Impingement.
- MRI:
- Rarely needed unless suspecting AVN or infection.
SUBTALAR PAIN
↓
X-RAY: JOINT NARROWING
↓
DIAGNOSTIC BLOCK
(To confirm source)
┌───────┴───────┐
RELIEF NO RELIEF
↓ (Look at Ankle/Tendons)
TRUE ST OA
↓
CONSERVATIVE
(Brace, Virgin, Steroid)
↓
FAILED?
↓
SURGERY
(Subtalar Fusion)
Indications
- Mild symptoms.
- Preserved motion.
- Contraindications to surgery.
Protocol
- Bracing:
- ASO / Lace-up: Mild support.
- UBC / Gauntlet: Rigid leather brace to lock inversion/eversion.
- Footwear: High-top hiking boots.
- Injections:
- Corticosteroid: Into the Sinus Tarsi. Effective.
Subtalar Arthrodesis (Fusion)
The Gold Standard.
1. In Situ Fusion
- Indication: Arthritis with minimal deformity.
- Technique:
- Incision over Sinus Tarsi (Ollier's approach).
- Debride cartilage from posterior facet.
- Fixation: 1 or 2 large cannulated screws (6.5/7.3mm) from Heel to Talus.
- Outcome: Excellent pain relief.
2. Distraction Bone Block Fusion
- Indication: Arthritis + Loss of Height (Collapsed Calcaneus).
- Rationale: The collapsed calcaneus causes anterior ankle impingement (Talar declination decreases). We need to jack the talus back up.
- Technique:
- Large structural bone graft (Iliac Crest) inserted into the posterior facet.
- Restores height and alignment.
3. Arthroscopic Fusion
- Indication: Mild deformity.
- Benefit: Less wound complications (sural nerve), faster healing.
Non-Union
- Rate: 5-10% (Higher in smokers).
- Revision requires bone graft.
Malposition
- Varus fusion: "Locks" rotation of the midfoot. Very rigid and painful.
- Correct Position: 5 degrees of Valgus is the sweet spot.
Prominent Hardware
- Heel screws can irritate shoe wear.
The Position Matters
- Mann et al: Demonstrated that fusing the subtalar joint in Valgus (5 deg) unlocks the transverse tarsal joint (Chopart) allowing some forefoot flexibility. Fusing in Varus locks the entire foot rigid.
Success Rate
- Eastham et al: Reported 90% fusion rate and reliable pain relief for post-traumatic cases.
The Condition
The "steering joint" under your ankle bone (which lets your foot rock side-to-side) is worn out. This is usually from that heel fracture you had years ago.
The Problem
Because it's rough and stiff, walking on anything but a flat floor hurts deeply in the heel.
The Surgery
We will fuse (glue) the two bones together.
- Will I walk normally? On flat ground, yes. You won't notice much difference because it's already stiff.
- Will I run? Jogging is possible.
- Can I walk on the beach? It will be harder, as your foot won't til to match the sand.
- Eastham ME, et al. Subtalar arthrodesis for post-traumatic arthritis. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2000.
- Thermann H, et al. Subtalar fusion: indications and technique. Foot Ankle Clin. 2002.
- Sanders R, et al. Operative treatment of displaced intra-articular calcaneal fractures. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1993.
Q1: What is the optimal position for Subtalar Fusion? A: 5 degrees of Valgus. This unlocks the transverse tarsal joint (Chopart), preserving some midfoot motion. Varus fusion locks the midfoot and causes lateral column overload.
Q2: Describe the "Distraction Bone Block" fusion. A: Used for malunited calcaneal fractures with loss of height. A tricortical iliac crest graft is inserted into the posterior facet to restore calcaneal height/talar inclination and relieve anterior ankle impingement.
Q3: Which view is best for assessing the Subtalar Joint? A: Broiden View: Internal rotation oblique views at variable angles (10, 20, 30, 40 degrees) to scan the posterior facet. Or CT.
Q4: Where do you place the screw for fusion? A: Typically from the posterior-inferior heel (calcaneus), directed antero-medially into the neck/body of the Talus.
(End of Topic)