Both Bone Forearm Fracture (Paediatric)
Summary
Both Bone Forearm Fractures (BBFF) are extremely common in children, typically resulting from falls onto an outstretched hand (FOOSH) or direct trauma (playground, trampoline). The fractures involve both the radius and ulna shafts simultaneously. Children's fractures differ fundamentally from adults due to the growth plate (physis), periosteum (thicker and stronger), and remodelling potential. Most paediatric BBFFs can be treated with closed reduction and casting, as the thick periosteal sleeve provides stability and children's bones remodel. However, unstable, displaced, or older child fractures may require internal fixation (K-wires or Titanium Elastic Nails – TENS).
Key Facts
- Common Injury: Peak age 10-12 years (active, before skeletal maturity).
- Mechanism: FOOSH (Fall Onto Outstretched Hand), direct blow.
- Fracture Types: Greenstick, Buckle (Torus), Complete, Plastic Deformation.
- Treatment (Children): Closed Reduction + Full Arm Cast (majority). K-wires/TENS if unstable.
- Treatment (Adults): ORIF with compression plates is standard (limited remodelling).
- Key Complication: Compartment Syndrome. Refracture after removal of hardware.
- Remodelling: Excellent in young children; <10 degrees angulation at <10 years will remodel.
Clinical Pearls
"The 10-10 Rule": Up to 10 degrees of angulation can be accepted in a child under 10 years because it will remodel. Malrotation does NOT remodel well.
"Greenstick = Incomplete Fracture": The cortex is broken on the convex side but intact on the concave side. The intact periosteum acts as a hinge, providing stability but risking re-angulation if not corrected.
"Complete the Fracture": In a Greenstick fracture, you may need to complete the fracture (break the intact cortex) to allow proper reduction and prevent springback.
Beware Compartment Syndrome: Any child with severe pain out of proportion to injury, especially pain on passive finger extension, requires urgent fasciotomy. Do NOT dismiss as "normal post-fracture pain".
Why This Matters Clinically
Forearm fractures are bread-and-butter paediatrics. Knowing which fractures are stable (buckle) versus unstable (displaced/angulated), understanding acceptable alignment for age, and recognising the red flags (compartment syndrome, neurovascular injury) is essential for safe management.
Incidence
- Forearm Fractures: Most common fractures in children.
- Peak Age: 10-12 years (high activity, bone transitioning from child to adolescent).
- Sex: Boys > Girls (~2:1).
Mechanism of Injury
| Mechanism | Percentage |
|---|---|
| Fall from Height (Playground, Trampoline) | ~40% |
| Sports Injury | ~30% |
| Direct Blow | ~20% |
| Road Traffic Accident | ~10% (Higher energy). |
Paediatric Bone Properties
Why children's bones fracture differently.
| Property | Child | Adult |
|---|---|---|
| Periosteum | Thick, Strong. Resists displacement. | Thin, Brittle. |
| Bone Porosity | More porous. | Less porous. |
| Physis (Growth Plate) | Present. Zone of weakness. Allows remodelling. | Closed/Fused. |
| Remodelling Potential | Excellent (especially <10 years, near physis). | Minimal. |
Fracture Patterns
| Pattern | Description | Stability |
|---|---|---|
| Buckle (Torus) | Cortical compression failure. Wrinkling on one side. Common at metaphysis. | Stable. Cast or splint. |
| Greenstick | Incomplete fracture. One cortex broken, one intact (bent). | Moderate. May need to "complete" for reduction. |
| Plastic Deformation (Bowing) | Bone bends but does not break. Microscopic failure. | Stable but may prevent reduction of adjacent bone. |
| Complete (Displaced) | Both cortices broken. Overriding/angulated. | Unstable. May need fixation. |
Deformity Patterns: Why Does the Bone Bend This Way?
Understanding muscle forces.
| Fracture Level | Typical Deformity | Muscle Force |
|---|---|---|
| Proximal 1/3 Radius | Supination of proximal fragment. | Supinator and Biceps pull proximal fragment into supination. |
| Middle 1/3 | Neutral or mild pronation. | Balanced forces. |
| Distal 1/3 Radius | Pronation of distal fragment. | Pronator Quadratus pulls distal fragment into pronation. |
Implication for Casting: The forearm should be immobilised in a position that relaxes the deforming muscles:
- Proximal fractures: Cast in Supination.
- Distal fractures: Cast in Neutral to Pronation.
Forearm Anatomy Essentials
- Radius & Ulna: Joined by Interosseous Membrane (IOM).
- Pronation/Supination: Requires normal anatomical alignment. Even small angular deformity can limit rotation.
- Muscle Forces: Pronator Teres (proximal radius), Pronator Quadratus (distal radius) – cause pronation deformity.
Symptoms
| Symptom | Notes |
|---|---|
| Pain | Localised to forearm. Worse with movement. |
| Swelling | Often significant. |
| Deformity | "S-shaped" or "Dinner Fork" (if displaced). May be subtle in greenstick. |
| Loss of Function | Unable or unwilling to use arm. |
| History of Fall | FOOSH typical. Direct blow. |
Clinical Signs
| Sign | Description |
|---|---|
| Angulation / Bowing | Visible on inspection. |
| Point Tenderness | Over fracture site(s). |
| Crepitus | Grating sound (Do not actively elicit – it's painful!). |
| Reduced Range of Motion | Pronation/Supination limited/painful. |
| Skin Integrity | Check for open fracture. |
Neurovascular Assessment (Critical)
| Structure | Test |
|---|---|
| Radial Nerve (Superficial) | Sensation – Dorsum of 1st web space. |
| Median Nerve | Sensation – Palmar aspect of thumb/index. Motor – OK sign, Thumb opposition. |
| Ulnar Nerve | Sensation – Little finger. Motor – Finger abduction/adduction. |
| Radial Artery | Palpate pulse at wrist. |
| Ulnar Artery | Palpate pulse at wrist. |
| Capillary Refill | <2 seconds in nail beds. |
Examination Steps
- Look: Swelling, Deformity, Bruising, Skin integrity (Open fracture?).
- Feel: Point tenderness. Compartments (Tense?). Pulses.
- Move: Hold in position. Do NOT manipulate unnecessarily.
- Neurovascular Status: Motor/Sensory/Vascular as above. Document before and after any intervention.
Compartment Syndrome: The 6 Ps
| "P" | Description |
|---|---|
| Pain | Out of proportion. Pain on passive stretch of fingers. EARLY AND MOST RELIABLE SIGN. |
| Pallor | Late sign. |
| Paraesthesia | Numbness, Tingling. Early. |
| Paralysis | Very late. |
| Pulselessness | Very late. Presence of pulses does NOT exclude compartment syndrome. |
| Pressure | Palpably tense compartments. |
Imaging
| Investigation | Details |
|---|---|
| X-ray: AP & Lateral Forearm | Standard. Include wrist and elbow joints. |
| Assess: Fracture site, Angulation (degrees), Displacement (%), Rotation, Associated injuries (Galeazzi, Monteggia). |
Key Radiographic Points
| Feature | What to Look For |
|---|---|
| Angulation | Measure apex angle. <10 degrees acceptable in <10 years (10-10 Rule). |
| Displacement | % of cortex apposition. >0% may be acceptable in young children. Bayonet apposition (overlap) acceptable if angulation OK. |
| Rotation | Look at width of bone at fracture site – asymmetry suggests rotation. Difficult to assess on plain films. |
| Associated Injuries | Always check proximal and distal joints! Monteggia (Ulna #, Radial head dislocation). Galeazzi (Radius #, DRUJ dislocation). |
Drill Down: Monteggia vs Galeazzi
Classic fracture-dislocation patterns.
| Pattern | Fracture | Dislocation |
|---|---|---|
| Monteggia | Proximal Ulna shaft. | Radial Head dislocation (check line of radius points to capitellum). |
| Galeazzi | Distal Radius shaft. | Distal Radio-Ulnar Joint (DRUJ) dislocation. |
Mnemonic: GRUMPS – Galeazzi = Radius + DRUJ. Monteggia = Ulna + Radial Head.
Management Algorithm
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ BOTH BONE FOREARM FRACTURE (CHILD) │
├─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│ │
│ STEP 1: Assess & Splint │
│ ├── Neurovascular exam (Document!). │
│ ├── Analgesia (Paracetamol + Ibuprofen +/- Nasal Diamorphine). │
│ └── Immobilise in Above-Elbow Backslab. │
│ │
│ STEP 2: X-ray (Include Wrist & Elbow Joints) │
│ │
│ STEP 3: Fracture Classification │
│ ├── Stable (Buckle): Splint/Cast 4 weeks. Clinic follow-up. │
│ ├── Greenstick (Minimally displaced): MUA + Full Cast. │
│ └── Complete/Displaced: MUA +/- TENS/K-wires. │
│ │
│ STEP 4: Acceptable Alignment (Child) │
│ ├── Angulation: <10° if age <10. <5° if older. │
│ └── Displacement: <50% acceptable if angulation OK. │
│ └── Rotation: NOT acceptable. Will not remodel. │
│ │
│ STEP 5: Reduction (If Needed) │
│ ├── Under Sedation (Ketamine) or GA. │
│ ├── Technique: Traction, Correct Angulation, Pressure over apex. │
│ └── Post-reduction X-ray. Repeat neurovascular exam. │
│ │
│ STEP 6: Immobilisation │
│ ├── Full Arm (Above-Elbow) Cast. │
│ ├── Position: Elbow 90°. Forearm: Depends on fracture level. │
│ └── Mould cast: "Oval" shape (not round). │
│ │
│ STEP 7: Operative Fixation (Indications) │
│ ├── Unstable after reduction. │
│ ├── Unacceptable alignment post-MUA. │
│ ├── Open fracture. │
│ ├── Multiple trauma. │
│ └── Options: K-wires (Simple). TENS (Elastic Nails). │
│ │
│ STEP 8: Follow-Up │
│ ├── X-ray in cast at 1-2 weeks (Check for loss of position). │
│ ├── Total immobilisation: 4-6 weeks. │
│ └── Refracture risk: Advise no contact sports for 3 months. │
│ │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
Immobilisation: Cast Specifics
| Aspect | Detail |
|---|---|
| Type | Full Arm (Above Elbow) Cast. |
| Elbow Position | 90 degrees flexion. |
| Forearm Rotation | Neutral to slight supination. (Some vary based on fracture site – proximal = supination, distal = neutral). |
| Moulding | "Interosseous Mould" – Flatten AP to create oval shape. This stabilises the fracture and prevents re-rotation. |
| Duration | 4-6 weeks depending on age and healing. |
Drill Down: The 3-Point Moulding Technique
How to create a stable cast.
- Apply Padding & Plaster: Standard application.
- Moulding (While wet):
- Apply pressure at 3 points: Apex of fracture (push down), proximal and distal to fracture (push opposite direction).
- Create an "Interosseous Mould" – Flatten the forearm from dorsal-volar to create an oval cross-section. This maintains the interosseous space and prevents rotation.
- Check: Position should be maintained. Repeat X-ray immediately post-application.
Historical Context: Evolution of Casting
Highlights in fracture immobilisation.
- Ancient Egypt: Stiffened linen bandages with resins.
- Plaster of Paris (1852): Antonius Mathijsen (Dutch military surgeon) developed plaster bandages. Revolutionised fracture care.
- Fibreglass (1970s): Lighter, waterproof option.
- TENS Nails (Modern): Minimally invasive fixation for unstable fractures.
Casting Pitfalls
| Pitfall | Consequence | Prevention |
|---|---|---|
| Too Tight | Compartment Syndrome. | Apply over padding. Split if swelling expected. |
| Round Cross-Section | Rotation. Instability. | Use Interosseous/3-Point mould. |
| Short Cast (Below Elbow) | Unstable. Forearm rotates. | Use Full Arm (Above Elbow) cast. |
| Loose Cast | Slippage. Loss of position. | Re-apply if loose. |
Operative Options
| Technique | Description | Indication |
|---|---|---|
| K-Wires (Percutaneous) | Wires passed across fracture site. | Simple unstable fractures. Smaller children. |
| TENS (Titanium Elastic Nails) | Flexible nails inserted intramedullary. | Older children. More stable fixation. |
| ORIF (Plates) | Open reduction, plate fixation. | Adolescents near skeletal maturity. Adult-pattern injury. |
Drill Down: TENS vs K-Wires
| Feature | TENS | K-Wires |
|---|---|---|
| Stability | Better rotational control. | Less. |
| Technique | Intramedullary. Two nails per bone (pre-bent). | Percutaneous. Often single wire per fragment. |
| Removal | Easier. Usually 3-6 months. | Easier. Usually 4-6 weeks. |
| Age | Older children (> years). | Younger children. |
| Complication | Notes |
|---|---|
| Compartment Syndrome | Emergency. Pain on passive stretch. Tight forearm. Needs fasciotomy within 6 hours. |
| Malunion | Angulation or rotation. May limit pronation/supination. Younger children remodel. |
| Refracture | Common (~10%). Often at original site. Risk highest 3-6 months post-union. |
| Non-Union | Rare in children. |
| Infection | Risk with open fractures or surgical fixation. |
| Stiffness | Usually temporary. Physio rarely needed in children. |
| Synostosis | Bone bridge between radius and ulna. Limits rotation. Rare. More common if high-energy or same-level fractures. |
Drill Down: Refracture Prevention
A key counselling point.
- Risk Period: First 3-6 months after cast removal. Bone is weaker during remodelling.
- Advice: Avoid contact sports, climbing, trampolines for at least 3 months post-removal.
- Refracture Management: Usually requires re-reduction and re-casting. May need more robust fixation if recurrent.
Prognosis
- Excellent in Children: Younger children have superb remodelling capacity.
- Functional Outcome: Almost all children regain full range of motion.
- Long-Term: No significant disability expected if properly managed.
Remodelling Potential
| Factor | Better Remodelling | Worse Remodelling |
|---|---|---|
| Age | Younger (<8-10 years). | Older (>0 years). |
| Fracture Location | Near physis (distal). | Mid-diaphyseal. |
| Deformity Plane | In the plane of joint motion (Sagittal). | Angulation or Rotation. |
| Rotation | Does NOT remodel. | - |
Key Guidelines
| Guideline | Organisation | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| AO Pediatric Long Bone Fractures | AO Foundation | Gold standard reference. |
| BOAST Guidance (Children's Fractures) | BOA/BSCOS | UK-specific. Standards of care. |
Evidence Levels
| Intervention | Evidence |
|---|---|
| Closed Reduction + Casting for stable fractures | High (Standard of Care). |
| TENS for unstable fractures | Moderate (Observational, RCTs). |
| Accepting <10° angulation in <10 years | High (Remodelling literature). |
Scenario 1:
- Stem: 8-year-old falls from monkey bars. X-ray shows both bone forearm fracture with 15 degrees angulation at the radius mid-shaft. What is the plan?
- Answer: Acceptable angulation for age is ~10 degrees. 15 degrees may not fully remodel. MUA (Manipulation Under Anaesthesia) and full arm cast. Repeat X-ray post-reduction.
Scenario 2:
- Stem: A 7-year-old in cast for BBFF returns complaining of severe pain in the forearm, worse on passive finger extension. What is your concern and action?
- Answer: Compartment Syndrome until proven otherwise. Split cast immediately (all layers). Elevate. If no improvement – urgent fasciotomy.
Scenario 3:
- Stem: What is the "10-10 Rule"?
- Answer: Up to 10 degrees of angulation is acceptable in a child under 10 years old because the bone will remodel.
Scenario 4:
- Stem: What is a Monteggia fracture-dislocation?
- Answer: Fracture of the proximal ulna shaft with dislocation of the radial head. Must always check the radiocapitellar line (line through radius should pass through capitellum on all views).
Scenario 5:
- Stem: A child had a BBFF treated in cast. Now 3 months post-removal, they sustain another fall and refracture the same site. Comment on risk factors and management.
- Answer: Refracture is common (~10%), especially in the first 3-6 months when bone is weakened during remodelling. Management: Re-reduction and casting. Consider TENS nails if recurrent or unstable. Advise no contact sports for 3 months after healing.
| Scenario | Urgency | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Closed buckle fracture, no angulation | Routine | Splint. Fracture clinic 1-2 weeks. |
| Greenstick, mild angulation (<10° and <10 years) | Routine | MUA if needed. Cast. Fracture clinic. |
| Displaced/Angulated BBFF | Same-Day | Orthopaedic review. MUA +/- fixation. |
| Open Fracture | Emergency | A&E. IV Antibiotics. Theatre for debridement/fixation. |
| Neurovascular deficit | Emergency | Orthopaedic emergency. Immediate reduction/assessment. |
| Suspected Compartment Syndrome | Critical Emergency | Split cast. If no improvement: Fasciotomy within 6 hours. |
What is a Both Bone Forearm Fracture?
Your child has broken both of the bones in their forearm – the radius and the ulna. This is a common injury in children, usually from a fall.
How is it treated?
Most of these fractures can be treated with a plaster cast covering the arm from above the elbow to the hand. Sometimes the doctor needs to straighten the bone first (closed reduction) while your child is asleep or sedated.
If the break is unstable, your child may need a small operation to put in wires or flexible nails to hold the bones in place.
How long is recovery?
- Cast: Usually worn for 4-6 weeks.
- After cast removal: Avoid rough play, trampolines, and contact sports for at least 3 months to reduce the risk of re-breaking the bone.
When should I worry?
Bring your child back immediately if:
- Severe pain that is getting worse, not better.
- Fingers go pale, blue, numb, or cold.
- They cannot move their fingers properly.
- The cast feels very tight.
Key Counselling Points (For Parents)
- Remodelling: "Children's bones are amazing at healing. Even if it doesn't look perfectly straight on the X-ray, the bone will often straighten itself as your child grows."
- Keep Cast Dry: "No baths or swimming. Cover with a plastic bag in the shower."
- Elevation: "Keep the arm raised above heart level to reduce swelling."
- Activity Restriction: "After the cast comes off, no trampolines, climbing frames, or contact sports for 3 months."
Cast Care Instructions (Patient Handout Content)
Give written instructions to all families.
| Instruction | Detail |
|---|---|
| Keep Dry | Cover with plastic bag for showers. No swimming/baths. |
| Elevation | Keep arm raised above heart level when resting. |
| Watch Fingers | Check colour, warmth, movement frequently. |
| Don't Insert Objects | No scratching inside cast with pencils, etc. |
| Report Damage | If cast cracks or gets wet, contact hospital. |
Physiotherapy (Post-Cast Removal)
Usually recovery is spontaneous – formal physio rarely needed.
| Age Group | Approach |
|---|---|
| Young Children (<8) | Self-mobilisation through play. Full recovery expected. Formal physio not needed. |
| Older Children / Adolescents | May benefit from gentle ROM exercises if stiff. Usually resolves within 4-6 weeks. |
| Exercises | Pronation/Supination (Turning palm up/down). Elbow flexion/extension. Wrist flexion/extension. |
| Return to Sport | 3 months minimum. May need gradual return to contact sports. |
Red Flags to Parents (Emergency Card)
Give this list to every family at discharge. 🚨 Bring your child IMMEDIATELY if:
- Severe pain that is getting worse, not better.
- Fingers turn white, blue, or cold.
- Fingers become very swollen or cannot move.
- Numbness or tingling in fingers.
- Foul smell or discharge from under cast.
Special Populations
| Population | Considerations |
|---|---|
| NAI (Non-Accidental Injury) | Consider if mechanism unclear, multiple injuries, delay in presentation. Safeguarding referral. |
| Osteogenesis Imperfecta | Brittle bones. Multiple fractures with minimal trauma. Wormian bones on skull X-ray. Refer Genetics. |
| Pathological Fracture | If fracture appears abnormal or with minimal trauma, consider underlying bone disease (tumour, cyst). |
| Standard | Target |
|---|---|
| Neurovascular status documented pre- and post-reduction | 100% |
| X-rays include wrist and elbow joints | 100% |
| Reduction performed under adequate sedation/GA | 100% |
| Post-reduction X-ray obtained | 100% |
| Patients with suspected Compartment Syndrome assessed within 30 mins | 100% |
| Refracture rate at 1 year | <10% |
| Follow-up X-ray in cast at 1-2 weeks | >5% |
- AO Surgery Reference: Pediatric Forearm Fractures. Link
- BOAST Standards for Children's Fractures. British Orthopaedic Association. Link
- Price CT, et al. Forearm Fractures in Children. Instr Course Lect. 2012. PMID: 22301235
Medical Disclaimer: MedVellum content is for educational purposes and clinical reference. If your child has a suspected fracture, seek medical attention promptly.